4 stars (5)
- Best Western Plus Beach Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Gulfview Manor Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Hilton Grand Vacations Seawacht On The Bay Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Marina Village At Snug Harbor Fort Myers Beach
- Pink Shell Beach Resort & Marina Fort Myers Beach
3 stars (21)
- Beach Shell Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Diamond Head Beach Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Edgewater Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Gullwing Beach Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Hampton Inn & Suites Fort Myers Beach/Sanibel Gateway
- Harbour House At The Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites - Ft Myers Beach-Sanibel Gateway, An Ihg Hotel Fort Myers Beach
- Latitude 26 Waterfront Resort And Marina Fort Myers Beach
- Lovers Key Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Manatee Bay Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Mango Street Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Mariners Boat House & Beach Club
- Matanzas Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Myerside Resort And Cottages Fort Myers Beach
- Outrigger Beach Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Pointe Estero Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Silver Sands Villas Fort Myers Beach
- The Bay Inn At The Lani Kai Fort Myers Beach
- The Neptune Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Tiki On The Beach Hotel Fort Myers Beach
- Wyndham Garden Fort Myers Beach
2 stars (20)
- Caribbean Beach Club Fort Myers Beach
- Carousel Beach Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Casa Playa Beach Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Dolphin Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Edison Beach House Fort Myers Beach
- Flamingo Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Hidden Harbor Suites Fort Myers Beach
- Hideaway Village Fort Myers Beach
- Indian Creek Hotel Fort Myers Beach
- La Villa Resort Fort Myers Beach
- Lani Kai Island Resort (Adults Only) Fort Myers Beach
- Latitude 26 Waterfront Boutique Resort - Fort Myers Beach
- Pierview Hotel And Suites Fort Myers Beach
- Sandy Beach Fort Myers Beach
- Shipwreck Motel Fort Myers Beach
- Sun Deck Inn & Suites Fort Myers Beach
- Tahitian Inn Fort Myers Beach
- The Holiday Court Villas And Suites Fort Myers Beach
- The Sea Gypsy Inn Fort Myers Beach
- Tropical Sands Resort Fort Myers Beach